Antithetical Arts: On the Ancient Quarrel Between Literature by Peter Kivy PDF

By Peter Kivy

ISBN-10: 0199562806

ISBN-13: 9780199562800

Antithetical Arts constitutes a defence of musical formalism opposed to those that could placed literary interpretations at the absolute track canon. partly I, the historic origins of either the literary interpretation of absolute track and musical formalism are laid out. partially II, particular makes an attempt to place literary interpretations on a variety of works of absolutely the tune canon are tested and criticized. eventually, partially III, the query is raised as to what the human importance of absolute song is, if it doesn't lie in its representational or narrative content material. the answer's that, as but, philosophy has no solution, and that the query will be thought of an immense one for philosophers of paintings to think about, and to attempt to reply to with out entice representational or narrative content material.

Show description

Read Online or Download Antithetical Arts: On the Ancient Quarrel Between Literature and Music PDF

Similar aesthetics books

Download e-book for kindle: The Search for the Beautiful Woman: A Cultural History of by Cho Kyo

Whereas a slim physique is a prerequisite for good looks this present day, plump girls have been thought of perfect in Tang Dynasty China and Heian-period Japan. beginning round the Southern tune interval in China, certain ft symbolized the recognition of girls. yet in Japan, shaved eyebrows and blackened the teeth lengthy have been markers of loveliness.

Get Le film-événement : Esthétique, politique et société dans le PDF

Dans l’histoire du cinéma mondial, des œuvres de fiction s’affirment non seulement comme des succès commerciaux mais aussi comme des événements politiques, intellectuels et sociaux. Leur présentation au public engendre en effet, dans los angeles sphère des médias et dans l’espace des pouvoirs, des débats nombreux, des controverses décisives, des affrontements aigus.

Get Animals in the Classical World: Ethical Perspectives from PDF

How have been non-human animals taken care of within the Classical global, and the way did historical authors checklist their responses to animals in Greek and Roman existence? The civilisations of Greece and Rome left specific files in their event and evaluations of animals: in those societies, which practised mass sacrifice and large-scale public animal hunts, in addition to being economically reliant on animal strength and items, how have been animals truly taken care of and the way was once it appropriate to regard them?

Download e-book for iPad: Showing, Sensing, and Seeming: Distinctively Sensory by Dominic Gregory

Sure representations are certain in a unique strategy to our sensory capacities. Many images convey issues as having a look definite methods, for example, whereas auditory psychological pictures exhibit issues as sounding convinced methods. What do all these distinctively sensory representations have in universal, and what makes them diversified from representations of different types?

Extra info for Antithetical Arts: On the Ancient Quarrel Between Literature and Music

Sample text

We feel that artworks have ideational content in a very different way. We feel that their ideational content, unlike that of non-artistic means of expression, is somehow ineffable: you cannot express what an artwork ‘‘says’’ in any other form than that in which the artwork ‘‘says’’ it. ¹² Critique of Aesthetic Judgement, 175–6 (§49). designs à la grecque 37 Artworks do indeed have manifest content, susceptible of paraphrase, and this content does indeed perform a vital function: it sets going a train of aesthetic ideas.

That one could do that, with regard either to color vibrations or sound vibrations, he says, ‘‘. . I very much doubt . . ’’ Thus, it seems, musical sound cannot be perceived as form, so music cannot be a fine, but must be an agreeable art. There is a catch, however, namely, that in the third edition of the Critique of Judgment, ‘‘I very much doubt’’ is altered to read: ‘‘which I ⁵ Immanuel Kant, Critique of Judgment, trans. J. H. Bernard (New York: Hafner, 1951), 60 (§14). designs à la grecque 33 still in no way doubt .

Kant’s notion, as I read him, is motivated by these considerations. If the content of an artwork were merely what I would call its ‘‘manifest’’ content, susceptible of paraphrase, then there would be nothing special about it. You could get it from any number of other forms of expression, and that would leave artworks with no special role or function of their own. But our intuitions run in a different direction. We feel that artworks have ideational content in a very different way. We feel that their ideational content, unlike that of non-artistic means of expression, is somehow ineffable: you cannot express what an artwork ‘‘says’’ in any other form than that in which the artwork ‘‘says’’ it.

Download PDF sample

Antithetical Arts: On the Ancient Quarrel Between Literature and Music by Peter Kivy


by Steven
4.2

Rated 4.34 of 5 – based on 36 votes

Related posts